Showing posts with label contracts. Show all posts
Showing posts with label contracts. Show all posts

Tuesday, May 5, 2015

Dynport Vaccine Co. LLC v. Lonza Biologics, Inc. (Maryland U.S.D.C.)


Filed: April 30, 2015

Opinion by: James K. Bredar

Holding: A basic ordering agreement that provides a framework for future contracts but fails to include mutuality of obligation is not by itself an enforceable contract.

Facts: Contractor and subcontractor entered into a basic ordering agreement, wherein defendant “agreed to provide certain services, pursuant to task orders.” Plaintiff issued various task orders, including three specific task orders mentioned in the complaint. Plaintiff brought suit alleging it incurred significant costs because of defendant’s refusal to perform and its breach of the basic ordering agreement.

Defendant argued the basic ordering agreement was not an enforceable contract and, therefore, the claim of breach of contract failed to state a claim for relief. Defendant conceded that the task orders were binding and legally enforceable contracts, but noted that plaintiff did not rely on breach of the task orders for its breach of contract claims.

Analysis: The “meager case law available” provides that a basic ordering agreement “is not an enforceable contract, despite its use of terms typically used in the language of contracts.” The court likened a basic ordering agreement, which only provides the framework for future contracts, to an agreement to agree because “contractual obligations will arise only after an order is placed.” Under such an agreement “no obligations are assumed by either party until orders are given by the [plaintiff] and accepted by the [defendant].”

The court reviewed the language of the basic ordering agreement in question, concluded it lacked mutuality of obligation and found it to be unenforceable. However, as both parties agreed the task orders were enforceable contracts, the court redefined plaintiff’s count as claiming breach of contract as to those task orders.

The full opinion is available in PDF.

Wednesday, April 29, 2015

TBC, Inc. v. DEI Holdings, Inc. (Maryland U.S.D.C.)

Filed: March 24, 2015

Opinion by: Catherine D. Blake

Holdings:

(1)   A corporate entity, in acquiring the assets of a predecessor, cannot be held liable solely based on continued use of a predecessor’s trade name, sale of a predecessor’s products, and retention of some of a predecessor’s accounts and employees.  

(2)   When a party does not allege facts to show that a corporate parent used its subsidiary “as a mere shield for the perpetration of fraud,” that party does not state a claim against the parent for the subsidiary’s obligations.

(3)   A party may state a claim for breach of contract without alleging perfect performance of its own obligations under the contract.

(4)   Maryland law does not recognize an independent cause of action for breach of the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealings.

(5)   A party may obtain restitution on the theory of unjust enrichment, despite the existence of an express contract, when the party breaches the express contract.

Facts:

Parent Defendant ("Parent") was the corporate parent of two subsidiaries, Subsidiary 1 and Subsidiary 2.  Additionally, four divisions of Parent were unincorporated until they formed LLCs in February 2014. 

Plaintiff, an advertising and public relations agency, was hired by Subsidiary 1, a consumer electronics vendor, to provide marketing services.  In 2011, Subsidiary 1 agreed to pay Plaintiff $12,500 each month for 83 hours of work per month.  In 2012, Subsidiary 2 hired Plaintiff under a similar agreement.  Plaintiff performed work beyond the monthly retainer for both entities and was paid additional fees accordingly. 

Subsidiary 1 later retained Plaintiff to perform advertising and marketing services for a new line of products on the terms outlined in the 2011 contract.  In 2013, Plaintiff worked 3,000 more hours than the 83 hours per month contemplated in the 2011 contract.  Despite this additional work, Plaintiff was paid monthly fees in 2013 based on the budgeted 83 hours per month.  Based on the experience of its leadership, Subsidiary 1 knew based on the nature of the requested work that it would require substantially more than 83 hours each month. 

In June 2013, Plaintiff’s Executive Vice President (the “VP”) met with three executives of Parent to discuss compensation for Plaintiff’s work in excess of the monthly budget.  The executives assured the VP that Plaintiff would be paid in full for the additional hours.  In August 2013, one of Parent's executives again told the VP that Plaintiff would be paid in full, and Plaintiff continued to perform more work until the Parent's executives informed the VP in January 2014 that Plaintiff’s services would no longer be needed.  Plaintiff was never paid for the 3,000 hours of additional work performed in 2013.

In February 2014, four LLCs (the “LLC defendants”) were formed from the four unincorporated divisions of Parent.  Subsidiary 1 also merged into Subsidiary 2. 

In September 2014, Plaintiff sued Parent, Subsidiary 1, Subsidiary 2 and the four LLCs alleging, inter alia, breach of contract, breach of the covenant of good faith and fair dealings, and unjust enrichment.  All defendants moved to dismiss. 

Analysis: 

(1)   The court first considered whether Plaintiff stated a claim against the LLC defendants.  Under the general rule of corporate successor liability, a corporate entity acquiring assets from another entity does not acquire the liabilities of its predecessor.  An exception is where the successor entity is a “mere continuation or reincarnation” of the predecessor entity.  The exception applies where there is continuity among directors and management, common shareholder interest, and, in some cases, inadequate consideration in the transaction.  Use of the predecessor’s trade name, sale of a predecessor’s products, and retention of the predecessor’s accounts and employees will not alone suffice.  Because the contracts predated the existence of the LLC defendants, and Plaintiff only alleged the latter three factors, Plaintiff failed to state a claim against the LLC defendants.

(2)   Next, the court considered Plaintiff’s claims against Parent.  In general, a parent corporation is not liable for the obligations of its subsidiaries.  The “corporate veil” may be pierced only in circumstances when it is necessary to prevent fraud or enforce a paramount equity, i.e., when the parent uses the subsidiary as a “mere shield” to commit fraud.  Plaintiff never contracted directly with Parent, but instead it contracted with Subsidiary 1 and Subsidiary 2.  Because Plaintiff did not allege facts to support Parent’s use of its subsidiaries to perpetuate fraud, Plaintiff failed to state any cause of action against Parent. 

(3)   The court then turned to Plaintiff’s contract claim against Subsidiary 2.  To state a claim for breach of contract under Maryland law, a plaintiff must only show (1) the existence of a contractual obligation owed by defendant to the plaintiff and (2) a material breach of that obligation by the defendant.  A plaintiff is not required to show that it complied with every procedural obligation described in the agreement.  Here, Plaintiff did not allege that it had obtained approval for additional work or that timely billed for the work, but these omissions were not fatal to the claim.  Plaintiff met its burden by alleging that (1) Subsidiary 2 was contractually obligated to pay for additional services beyond those contemplated in the 83 hour budget and (2) Subsidiary 2 failed to pay Plaintiff in breach of that obligation. 

(4)   The court dismissed Plaintiff’s claim of breach of the covenant of good faith and fair dealings, noting that Maryland does not recognize this as an independent cause of action.

(5)   Lastly, the court addressed Plaintiff’s unjust enrichment claim.  In Maryland, a claim of unjust enrichment may not be brought where the subject of the claim is covered by an express contract.  An exception to this rule occurs when there has been a breach of contract, in which case a party may obtain restitution on the theory of unjust enrichment.  If a jury finds that Plaintiff did not substantially perform under the agreement, thereby rejecting Plaintiff’s contract claim, then Plaintiff may still recover for unjust enrichment.  Both the contract and unjust enrichment claims may stand as alternative, inconsistent theories of liability.

The opinion is available in PDF.

Wednesday, April 1, 2015

Falls Garden Condominium Ass’n, Inc. v. Falls Homeowners Ass’n, Inc. (Md. Court of Appeals)

Filed: January 27, 2015

Opinion by: Lynne A. Battaglia

Holding:  A letter of intent may be an enforceable contract where definite terms are included, signaling intent of the parties to be bound, and the material terms of a contract are included.  Further, where the letter of intent is unambiguous and constitutes an enforceable contract, it is unnecessary to have a plenary hearing on the merits of a motion to enforce a settlement agreement

Facts: The appeal arose out of the execution of a letter of intent which was the result of the settlement of litigation over the contested ownership of parking spaces.

Analysis:  Distinguishing Cochran v Norkunas, which held that the parties did not intend to be bound by a letter of intent and it was therefore unenforceable, the Court noted that in the present case the parties expressed their intent to be bound to the letter of intent through the definiteness of terms included therein.

In discerning the enforceability of the letter of intent the Court relied upon the often cited and influential treatise Corbin on Contracts, which divides cases where letters of intent have been an issue into a spectrum with four categories: (i) where the parties specifically say that they intend not to be bound until the formal writing is executed; (ii) cases where the parties clearly point out one or more specific matters on which they must yet agree before negotiations are concluded; (iii) cases where the parties express definite agreement on all necessary terms, and say nothing as to other relevant matters not essential, but that are often included in similar contracts; and (iv) cases like those of the third class, with the addition that the parties expressly state that they intend their present expressions to be a binding agreement or contract, and are thus conclusive as to the parties intent.  The Court indicated that the essential distinction between the indefinite middle two categories centers on the question as to whether the terms included in the document are definite or indefinite, which then informs the central question as to whether the parties intended to be bound and, thus, their mutual assent.  Under this framework of analysis, the Court finds the letter of intent to be enforcable due to the mutual assent of the parties, and the lease is not enforceable.

Following this line of reasoning, the Court noted that due to the absence of ambiguous terms in the letter of intent the trial judge need not entertain extrinsic evidence, especially if the evidence were to be of a self-serving nature, as in the present case.

The full opinion is available in PDF.

Thursday, March 26, 2015

Bank of Commerce v. Maryland Financial Bank (Maryland U.S.D.C.)

Filed: March 2, 2015

Opinion by: Ellen Lipton Hollander

Holdings:  The meaning of a contractual provision is not discerned by reading it in isolation, but by recognizing its relation to the other terms of the complete contractual relationship.

Extrinsic evidence indicating a party is entitled to proceeds of a foreclosure on a first out basis may only be considered if the underlying contract is ambiguous.

Facts:  Nearly two years after a loan was made, defendant purchased a 25% interest in the loan pursuant to a participation agreement.  The loan went into and remained in default despite various efforts to cure the default.  Plaintiff initiated a foreclosure proceeding.  The resulting foreclosure sale resulted in a loss on the loan. 

The parties disagreed as to how the foreclosure proceeds should be disbursed under the participation agreement.  Section 9(b) of the agreement provided that plaintiff “shall promptly remit to [defendant] its percentage interest first, as hereinabove specified, of all net proceeds received by [plaintiff] as a consequence of such foreclosure proceeding.”  The agreement did not define percentage interest.  Section 1 of the agreement provided that defendant’s “interest in the loan, expressed as a percentage, is 25.00%.”

Analysis:  Instead of receiving 25% of the foreclosure proceeds, defendant argued it was entitled to “its full 25% interest in the loan first, before the remaining foreclosure proceeds are distributed” because the terms pro rata and ratable were absent from Section 9(b).  The Court viewed defendant’s interpretation as being at odds with the allocation of losses section of the agreement, which required ratable allocation of any losses on the loan.  The Court also noted that defendant, in selecting an option for priority of payments, chose “pro rata” rather than “first out” or “100%.”  Citing Atlantic Contracting & Material Co. Inc. v. Ulico Cas. Co., the Court stated “the meaning of a provision is not discerned by reading it in isolation, but by recognizing its relation to the other terms of complete contractual relationship.” 

Defendant also argued that the use of the word “first” in section 9(b) shifted a greater risk to plaintiff in the event of a default and subsequent foreclosure sale.  Plaintiff argued the word first refers to defendant receiving its 25% ratable interest, not defendant being remitted its entire investment.  The Court agreed and stated that contractual terms must be read by recognizing their relation to the other contractual terms.

The Court also stated that defendant’s interpretation would effectively convert defendant’s participating investment into a loan, which is generally inconsistent with a participation agreement.  The Court then reviewed several cases and factors to determine whether a transaction involves a participation interest or a loan. 

The Court declined to introduce extrinsic evidence, in the form of a letter attached to an e-mail, indicating defendant was entitled to proceeds on a first out basis.  The Court held that extrinsic evidence may only be considered if a contract is ambiguous and such ambiguity does not exist “simply because, in litigation, the parties offer different meanings to the language.”

The opinion is available in PDF.

Monday, March 23, 2015

Karen R. Goozh v. Howard Richmond (Cir. Ct. Mont. Cnty.)


Filed: July 8, 2014

Opinion by: Ronald B. Rubin

Holding: A stockholders’ agreement that expired upon the “dissolution” of the company was terminated when the company was administratively dissolved for failure to file a regular report, despite having its charter later reinstated when the failure was cured.

Facts: Stockholders in a Washington, D.C., company entered into a stockholders’ agreement that included a provision whereby the agreement would terminate upon the “liquidation or dissolution of the Company.” The company’s charter was then revoked twice after it failed to file a required biennial report with the District of Columbia Department of Consumer and Regulatory Affairs. In each instance, the revocation was eventually annulled, but the Plaintiffs argued that the stockholder’ agreement remained terminated after the first revocation despite such reinstatement.

Analysis: The court noted that a different District of Columbia statute applied to each administrative dissolution of the company. In the second instance, the law stated that when a company’s charter was revoked and later restored, the restoration would “relate back” to the date of the administrative dissolution. In other words, the gap in the company’s continuity would effectively be erased.

The court found two D.C. cases instructive: In Accurate Construction Co. v. Washington, a contract entered into while a company’s charter was revoked was held to be unenforceable, and in T.K., Inc. v. National Community Reinvestment Coalition, Inc., the tenant under a commercial lease was found to have remained a valid party to the lease despite the revocation and subsequent reinstatement of its charter during the lease term.

Finding neither case dispositive, the court said that because the stockholders’ agreement failed to define the term dissolution, the plain meaning of the word should apply. The court acknowledged that the drafters may not have intended a “technical” or “administrative” dissolution of the company to terminate the agreement. Nevertheless, it held that a reasonable person would understand the word dissolution to include such events.

Although the case hinges on D.C. law, the court occasionally draws comparisons with Maryland law and cites Maryland law when discussing the effects of revival.

Full opinion is available in PDF.

Saturday, March 21, 2015

Tucker v. Specialized Loan Servicing, LLC (Maryland U.S.D.C.)

Filed: February 3, 2015

Opinion by: Paul W. Grimm

Holding: A creditor waives an express condition precedent to a loan modification when it signs and accepts payments under that modification without satisfaction of the condition precedent.  

Facts: Plaintiff purchased a home through a mortgage loan and deed of trust, which she jointly executed with her husband (“Husband,” collectively “Plaintiffs”).  The deed of trust provided that Plaintiff could modify the terms of the mortgage loan without Husband’s approval.  Plaintiff later applied to her mortgage servicer for a permanent loan modification.  The servicer returned a signed copy of the modification agreement (the “Modification”), which stated that the modification was effective as of February 1, 2010.  Despite language in the Modification requiring signatures from both mortgagors, Husband never signed.  Plaintiff made payments under the Modification, which the were accepted.  The servicer later assigned the loan to Defendants.  Plaintiff continued to make payments pursuant to the Modification, which Defendants rejected, insisting that the Modification was ineffective.  Defendants reported to credit agencies that Plaintiffs were in default and appointed trustees to foreclose on the home.

Plaintiffs filed an action alleging, inter alia, violations of the Maryland Consumer Debt Collection Act and the Maryland Consumer Protection Act, defamation, injurious falsehood, and breach of contract.  Defendants moved to dismiss.

Analysis: The Court found that all of Plaintiff’s claims hinged on the validity of the Modification. Defendants contended that the Modification was ineffective because the servicer never waived, in writing, the stated requirement of both signatures. The Court rejected this argument, reasoning that statements or actions may constitute waiver of a condition precedent in a contract. Although the Modification expressly required both signatures, the servicer waived this requirement through its actions of returning the signed Modification and accepting payments without Husband’s signature. After rejecting Defendants' statute of limitations arguments, the Court denied the motion to dismiss.

The opinion is available in PDF.

Wednesday, March 18, 2015

Knight v. Manufacturers & Traders Trust Co. (Maryland U.S.D.C.)


Filed: February 4, 2015

Opinion by: James K. Bredar

Holding: Under the Maryland Credit Agreement Act, Cts. & Jud. Proc., § 5-408, a borrower may not introduce extrinsic evidence to interpret ambiguities in a credit agreement where a claim for breach of contract is asserted as a means to directly defeat or attain modification of the credit agreement.

Facts: Plaintiffs obtained several loans from a bank secured by real property owned by plaintiffs. Within two years, the real property serving as collateral (the “property”) significantly declined in value and plaintiffs and the bank renegotiated the terms of the existing loans in a letter agreement. The letter agreement provided, among other things, that it was in the mutual interest of plaintiffs and the bank to have the property “engineered to obtain the highest and best use” and thus the bank agreed to pay for a market feasibility study and fifty-percent of reasonable costs for such engineering. Subsequently, the bank was placed into receivership and defendant purchased the bank’s assets, including the loans to plaintiffs. Neither the market feasibility study nor the re-engineering ever occurred and plaintiffs defaulted on the loans.

Plaintiffs alleged, among other things, that defendant breached the letter agreement because, during negotiations leading up to the letter agreement, the bank agreed to obtain the market feasibility study, not just pay for it. Plaintiffs did not allege, however, that the bank’s obligation had been reduced to writing. Defendant filed a motion to dismiss the claim.

Analysis: Applying an objective standard of contract interpretation, the Court found the letter agreement ambiguous as to which party was responsible for obtaining the market feasibility study. Further, the letter agreement was subject to the Maryland Credit Agreement Act, under which extrinsic evidence is barred in a dispute about a credit agreement if the borrower asserts a claim as a means to directly defeat or attain modification of the agreement. The court noted that extrinsic evidence nevertheless may be considered by a court if the borrower asserts a claim “notwithstanding the implicitly conceded enforceability” of the agreement, such as any claims that would serve as a set-off against any judgment. The Court found that plaintiffs’ allegations of the verbal agreement between them and the bank would modify the terms of the letter agreement and thus the Maryland Credit Agreement Act barred the Court from considering such evidence.

Although the letter agreement implied that when it was drafted, all parties expected a market feasibility study to take place, the Court found no evidence that either plaintiffs, the bank or defendant made an undertaking to obtain such study. This silence defeated plaintiffs’ allegations that defendant breached a contractual obligation and therefore the Court dismissed plaintiffs’ breach of contract claim against defendant.

In a footnote, the Court points out that if plaintiffs had alleged the bank promised to obtain the market feasibility study in writing, the court would face a “radically different” question, and such evidence would likely be considered in resolving the ambiguity in the letter agreement.

The full opinion is available in PDF.

Thursday, March 12, 2015

Elite Construction Team, Inc. v. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. (Maryland U.S.D.C.)

Filed:  March 2, 2015

Opinion by: James K. Bredar

Holding:  An unpaid subcontractor that has no privity with an owner may not prevail against such owner in a claim that the owner is unjustly enriched. 

Facts:  Defendant entered into contracts with a contractor to construct three stores.  Contractor entered into a subcontract with Plaintiff to perform certain site development services.  Plaintiff furnished labor, materials and extra work at the direction of Contractor.  Contractor failed to pay Plaintiff.  Plaintiff alleged Defendant withheld monies from Contractor in an amount equal to the amount Plaintiff claims it is owed.  Plaintiff asserted claims under a theory of breach of implied contract or quantum meruit. 

Analysis:  The Court relied on the Court of Appeals decision of Bennett Heating & Air Conditioning, Inc. v. NationsBank of Maryland, which recognized that claims in quantum meruit and implied contract are all aimed at achieving restitution.  Restitution is a restoration required to prevent unjust enrichment.  The Bennett court provided that an owner’s enrichment is not unjust when the owner gets no more than what was contracted for.  Instead, a subcontractor not in privity with the owner may obtain a judgment against the general contractor and seek through garnishment or subrogation the monies owed by the owner to the general contractor.  Because Plaintiff was not in privity of contract with Defendant, its claims failed.

The Court disagreed with Plaintiff’s argument that it was an intended beneficiary of the contracts between Defendant and the general contractor and, therefore, a constructive trust was created in Plaintiff’s favor.  The Court noted precedent that a constructive trust is a remedy for unjust enrichment, but found Bennett to “unequivocally establish” that Defendant is not unjustly enriched. The Court also noted that the contracts between the Defendant and the general contractor expressly disavow any interpretation that would “confer any rights upon any person who is not a party to the” contracts. 

The full opinion is available in PDF.

Thursday, February 13, 2014

Gregg Lapointe v. SIGMA TAU Pharmaceuticals, Inc.

Filed: September 11, 2013 

Opinion by Michael D. Mason 

Holdings:  (1) A parent corporation is allowed to interfere with the subsidiary's contracts without liability under the "unity of interest" doctrine.  This privilege is not absolute, however.  It does not exist if the parent acts contrary to the interests of the subsidiary or interferes with a contract with a third party by use of wrongful means.  The burden of establishing a privilege lies with the complaining party. 

(2) If a privilege is found, it would extend to a shareholder with a controlling interest in the parent corporation. 

Facts:  Plaintiffs, former employees of corporate defendant's wholly owned subsidiary, alleged that the corporate defendant and its largest shareholder (also an individually named defendant) tortuously interfered with plaintiffs' long-benefit plan causing a refusal to pay benefits to which plaintiffs were entitled.  


Defendants filed motion to dismiss arguing that even assuming wrongful interference, no liability exists when a parent interferes in a contract between its wholly owned subsidiary and a third party because there is a "unity of interest" between the parent and its subsidiary.  The largest shareholder of the parent also claimed benefit to this doctrine.


Analysis:  Although Maryland courts have discussed the issue of whether the unity of interest doctrine applies to tortious interference claims involving a parent corporation and its wholly owned subsidiary, they have not adopted it.  In Copperweld Corp. v. Independence Tube Corp., the U.S. Supreme Court held that a parent corporation could not be prosecuted for an antitrust violation involving its subsidiary because a parent and its wholly owned subsidiary have a complete unity of interest. 

However, as the principle relates to a parent corporation’s liability for tortious interference with the contractual agreement of its subsidiaries, most courts that have adopted the doctrine have done so with limitations.  In Waste Conversion Sys., Inc. v. Greenstone Indus., Inc., 33 S.W.3d 779, 781 (Tenn. 2000), the Supreme Court of Tennessee held that a parent could lose its privilege if (1) acting contrary to its wholly-owned subsidiary’s economic interests the parent can be considered a third party to its subsidiary's contractual relationship and can be held for tortuously interfering with that relationship; and (2) it employs wrongful means even if the parent does not act contrary to the subsidiary's best interest.  Wrongful means is defined to include misrepresentation of facts, fraud, threats, intimidation, as well as a number of other acts, including any other wrongful act recognized by statute or common law.  The burden of proof lies with the plaintiff.

The full opinion is available in PDF.




        Monday, January 27, 2014

        MHD-Rockland Inc. v. Aerospace Distributions Inc. (Maryland U.S.D.C.)

        Filed:  January 3, 2014

        Opinion by Catherine C. Blake

        Holdings:  (1) In a transaction between merchants, an acceptance that contains the words “subject to” along with additional terms does not render the acceptance “expressly made conditional on assent to the additional terms” for purposes of Section 2-207(1) of the Commercial Law Article.

        (2) In a transaction between merchants, objection to the condition of goods and the return of such goods is not a timely objection of additional terms in an acceptance for purposes of Section 2-207(2) of the Commercial Law Article. 
        Facts:  Plaintiff, through use of a purchase order, ordered four airplane wheel assemblies in “overhauled” condition from defendant.  Defendant sent the assemblies and an acknowledgment form representing that the assemblies were in overhauled condition.  The acknowledgment form further stated it was “subject to” the Conditions of Sale printed on the reverse side of the form, which purported to limit liability for consequential damages and disclaim any express or implied warranties.  Plaintiff returned two assemblies allegedly not in overhauled condition, which were therefore defective.  Disagreements arose whether the two returned assemblies were defective. 

        Plaintiff alleged, among other claims, breach of contract.  Defendant argued plaintiff should not be allowed to seek lost profits because the contract expressly foreclosed any warranty, including liability for consequential damages.  Plaintiff claimed it rejected the conditions upon return of the assemblies. 
        Analysis:  The Court applied Section 2-207 of the Commercial Law Article as the case involved a sale of goods between merchants.  Section 2-207 provides an acceptance containing additional terms is still an acceptance that forms a contract unless the “acceptance is expressly made conditional on assent to the additional or different terms.”  The Court noted that Maryland courts have not decided whether an acceptance “subject to” additional terms amounts to an acceptance “expressly made conditional.”  The Court agreed with cited precedent that concluded the “subject to” language does not make the acceptance expressly conditional on the buyer’s assent to the additional terms.  Accordingly, the Court held that defendant’s acceptance of the purchase order was not expressly made conditional on plaintiff’s assent to the additional terms in the Conditions of Sale.

        Section 2-207 further provides that if there is an acceptance, the additional terms become part of the contract between merchants unless: “(a) [t]he offer limits acceptance to the terms of the offer; (b) [t]hey materially alter it; or (c) [n]otification of objection to them has already been given or is given within a reasonable time after notice of them is received.”  The Court noted that the plaintiff did not allege how and when it rejected the additional terms.  The Court stated that plaintiff’s objection to the condition of the assemblies does not amount to a timely objection to the additional terms in the defendant’s acceptance.  The Court dismissed the claim for lost profits from the alleged breach of contract. 
        In a lengthy footnote, the Court also discussed an argument that the terms should be excluded from the contract because they materially alter the agreement.  The Court stated that such argument, if raised, would have failed under the applicable Maryland test. 

        The full opinion is available in PDF.

        Thursday, January 23, 2014

        Lomax v. Weinstock, Friedman & Friedman, P.A. (Maryland U.S.D.C.)

        Filed January 15, 2013

        Opinion by Judge Catherine C. Blake

        Holding: Under the doctrine of equitable estoppel, a party to a contract containing a mandatory arbitration provision cannot avoid arbitration of a claim against a nonsignatory to the subject contract when the basis for the claim is that contract.
         
        Facts: Plaintiff Lomax financed the purchase of a car with a loan obtained through a retail installment contract (the “RISC”) with Credit Acceptance Corporation (“CAC”).  After CAC repossessed and sold the car it retained Weinstock to obtain a deficiency judgment against Lomax.  Lomax filed suit against Weinstock alleging the firm violated the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act, the Maryland Consumer Debt Collection Act and the Maryland Consumer Protection Act. Weinstock filed a motion to dismiss or, in the alternative, to stay the action and compel arbitration based on the RISC’s mandatory arbitration provision.
         
        Analysis: It is settled that parties must submit claims to arbitration where they have a valid arbitration agreement and it covers the issues in dispute.  Lomax did not dispute the validity of the RISC or the arbitration agreement within it, but argued that Weinstock, as a nonsignatory to the RISC, could not invoke the arbitration clause.  The Court held, however, that when each of a signatory's claims against a nonsignatory makes reference to or presumes the existence of the written agreement, the signatory is equitably estopped from refusing to submit such claims to arbitration if the arbitration provision is sufficiently broad to encompass the claims.  Because Lomax relied on the RISC as the basis for her attempt to collect damages from Weinstock and the arbitration provision in the RISC was broadly worded so as to include claims against the seller’s attorneys, Lomax was estopped from disclaiming the mandatory arbitration provision contained in the RISC.
         
        The Court granted the motion to dismiss.

        The opinion is available in PDF. 

        Wednesday, January 15, 2014

        Kimberly Pinsky v. Pikesville Recreation Council (Ct. of Special Appeals)

        Filed: October 30, 2013
        Opinion by Judge Robert A. Zarnoch

        Held:

        Directors and officers of an unincorporated nonprofit association may be held liable for contracts entered into by the association if they authorized, assented to or ratified the contract in question.

        Facts:

        Defendant, an unincorporated nonprofit association, hired plaintiffs to work in a pre-school. Before the end of their respective contract terms, defendant terminated plaintiffs pursuant to letters of termination. Plaintiffs sued defendant and its individual officers and directors to recover payments still owed to them, plus treble damages, attorney's fees, and costs. After a three-day bench trial, the circuit court entered judgment for plaintiffs, but rejected the claims against the individual directors and officers. The court also declined to grant appellants' motions for sanctions and for attorney's fees and costs. Plaintiffs appealed  the adverse judgment with respect to the individual directors and officers and the court's rulings on sanctions, attorney's fees, and costs.

        Analysis:

        The Court of Special Appeals noted that as an unincorporated association, defendant had at least some formal organization, as it operated under a constitution, bylaws and policy manual. Citing Littleton v. Wells & McComas Council, 98 Md. 453, 455 (1904) and Restatement (Second) of Judgements Sec. 61 cmt. a (1982) the Court found that unincorporated associations had the right to sue and be sued and that a judgement against the association alone does not reach the assets of its members.  Further, although no law explicitly permits unincorporated associations to enter into contracts, the Court indicated that this is a long-recognized and uncontroversial power (see Miller v. Loyal Order of Moose Lodge No. 358, 179 Md. 350, 356).

        At common law, officers of an unincorporated association were personally liable for the debts of the association. Since the Court of Appeals= decision in Littleton, 98 Md. at 456, and the Legislature's subsequent enactment of the legislative predecessors to CJP  Sec. 11-105, a judgment rendered solely against an association does not, on its own, expose the association's officers to liability. Yet CJP Sec. 11-105 does not address whether the officers, if named personally, can be held liable in actions also brought against the association. The Court quoted Littleton, which observed that "[t]he statute does not take away the right existing at common law to sue the members of an unincorporated association, but the creditor has the option to sue either the association or the members; and, when the suit is against the former, a judgment obtained can only affect its joint property." The Court noted that it does not read Littleton as positing an either/or system of recovery.

        Officers and other agents of associations, such as the defendant, are statutorily protected from personal liability for damages in any suit if the association maintains insurance coverage. CJP Sec. 5-406(b). The Court noted that, absent such insurance coverage, personal liability could attach.  The Court then turned to the case law of other states for a better understanding of when officers are personally liable, and since the majority of states have not enacted comprehensive statutes on unincorporated associations, the common law still generally covers the principles of liability.  The Court found a distinction in the case law between for-profit and nonprofit associations.  Individual liability of a for-profit organization is analyzed under partnership principles; individual liability of a nonprofit association is analyzed under agency principles. Therefore, in nonprofit associations, "a member is personally responsible for a contract entered into by the nonprofit association only - if viewing him as though he were a principal and the association were his agent - that member authorized, assented to, or ratified the contract in question." (See Karl Rove & Co. v. Thornburgh, 39 F. 3d 1273, 1284).  The Court went on to discuss ratification, authorization and assent to a contract.

        The full opinion is available in PDF.

        Friday, November 8, 2013

        Dolan v. McQuaide (Ct. of Special Appeals)

        Filed: November 5, 2013
        Opinion by: Judge Albert J. Matricciani, Jr.

        Held: (1) There was no dispute of material fact on plaintiff's breach of contract and promissory estoppel claims where parties had discussed that plaintiff would help to "plan" the opening of the car wash business, but had not discussed or agreed upon the scope of plaintiff's services.

        (2) There was a dispute of material fact on plaintiff's claims for unjust enrichment where there was record evidence of the fair market value of her services.

        Facts: The plaintiff and defendant, began a romantic relationship in 1997. They were engaged to be married in 2002. Between 2000 and 2002, they decided to open a car wash business. In exchange for her efforts in planning the business, the defendant agreed that the plaintiff was to be an equal partner in the car wash business and share net profits. The plaintiff performed various services for the car wash business, including drafting a business plan, making financial projections, creating a web site, and writing contracts for the defendant to use with investors and service providers. In 2005, shortly before the car wash was to open, the parties ended their personal and professional relationship. The defendant did not compensate the plaintiff as promised. The plaintiff sued for breach of contract, promissory estoppel, accounting and unjust enrichment.The defendant moved for summary judgment on all claims and prevailed.

        Analysis: Breach of Contract and Promissory Estoppel Claims: a breach of contract claim cannot stand if terms are vague or uncertain. Robinson v. Gardiner, 196 Md. 213, 217 (1950). A clear and definite promise is required to sustain a claim of promissory estoppel. Pavel Enterprises, Inc. v. A.S. Johnson Co., Inc., 342 Md. 143, 166 (1996). Here, the parties spoke only in general terms about what the plaintiff would do in exchange for a share in the business. There was thus insufficient specificity to determine whether the plaintiff satisfied her obligations under the agreement. See Mogavero v. Silverstein, 142 Md. App. 259, 273 (2002). The plaintiff performed services, but she did so without having discussed them in detail at the time the alleged oral contract was formed.  Conduct alone cannot form an oral contract or bind another party in promissory estoppel. See generally Alternatives Unlimited, Inc v New Baltimore City Bd. of Sch. Comm'rs, 155 Md. App. 415 (2004). Moreover, there was no evidence from which a fact-finder could reasonably infer a definite set of promises sufficient to give rise to contract or promissory estoppel claims. Thus, there was no dispute of material fact on the claims of breach of contract and promissory estoppel, and summary judgment for the defendant was proper.

        Unjust Enrichment Claim: an unjust enrichment claim arises where there are three elements present: (1) a benefit conferred upon the defendant by the plaintiff; (2) appreciation or knowledge by defendant of the benefit; and (3) acceptance or retention of benefit such that it's inequitable for defendant to retain without payment of its value.  Hill v. Cross Country Settlements, LLC, 402 Md. 281, 295 (2007). The appropriate remedy for unjust enrichment is restitution for the plaintiff such that the defendant is no better or worse than he was ex ante. Assessing damages requires a computation of the value of the benefit actually received by the defendant. Here, the plaintiff provided evidence of the fair market value of the services she provided. While the fair market value did not conclusively establish the actual value of her services, such evidence created a genuine issue of fact for the fact-finder. Thus, summary judgment for the defendant on the unjust enrichment claim was unwarranted.

        The full opinion is available in .pdf.



        Wednesday, August 21, 2013

        Raglani v. Ripken Professional Baseball, d/b/a Aberdeen Ironbirds (Maryland U.S.D.C.)

        Filed: April 16, 2013
        Opinion by Judge Catherine C. Blake

        Held: Agreement requiring at-will employee to arbitrate disputes with employer, which recited only hiring and continued employment as consideration, which did not require employer to arbitrate, and which gave employer unilateral control over pool of potential arbitrators, was held unenforceable because it lacked mutuality of consideration and denied the employee access to a neutral arbitral forum.

        Facts: Plaintiff was an employee at the Defendant company who was terminated in 2011.  Plaintiff alleged that she was discriminated against and terminated because of her gender and filed suit under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and Maryland state law.

        When Plaintiff commenced employment with the Defendant company, she signed a Problem Support Policy that included “a valid and binding” arbitration agreement under which employees of the Defendant company promised to arbitrate disputes in consideration of only the employees’ hiring and continued employment.  Defendant had exclusive control over the list of potential arbitrators.  When an employee of Defendant elected to arbitrate a dispute, Defendant was to provide the employee with its list of qualified arbitrators from which the employee could choose.  The agreement required employees of the Defendant company to arbitrate but did not require the Defendant company to follow similar procedures or submit to arbitration.

        Defendant filed a motion to dismiss or to stay and compel arbitration pursuant to the arbitration agreement signed by Plaintiff.

        Analysis: Although the court acknowledged the Fourth Circuit’s liberal policy toward arbitration agreements, it emphasized it still must evaluate arbitration agreements as contracts.  The court therefore first analyzed whether the arbitration agreement was valid and enforceable.  The court found two independent reasons the arbitration agreement was unenforceable: (1) the agreement lacked consideration and (2) the agreement denied employees access to a neutral forum.  Because the arbitration agreement was unenforceable the court denied Defendant’s motion to dismiss the case or to stay and compel arbitration.

        First, like all contracts, arbitration agreements must contain adequate consideration.  Cheek v. United Healthcare of Mid-Atlantic, Inc., 835 A.2d 656, 661 (Md. 2003); Prima Paint Corp. v. Flood & Conklin Mfg. Co., 388 U.S. 395 (1967); Noohi v. Toll Bros., Inc., 708 F.3d 599, 609 (4th Cir. 2013); Hill v. Peoplesoft USA, Inc., 412 F.3d 540, 543-44 (4th Cir. 2005).  The court followed the logic laid out in Cheek, supra, to conclude that employment or continued employment is not alone adequate consideration for an employee’s promise to arbitrate.  Cheek, 835 A.2d at 666.  Because it did not require Defendant to submit to arbitration, the arbitration agreement was entirely “one-directional” and therefore lacked mutuality of consideration.

        Second, even if the arbitration agreement did have adequate consideration, it denied employees access to a neutral forum.  Although there is uncertainty as to whether an arbitration agreement that denies one party access to a neutral forum results in unconscionability, a material breach, or simply unenforceability of the agreement, courts agree that denial of access to a neutral forum in an arbitration agreement may make the agreement unenforceable.  Muriithi v. Shuttle Exp., Inc., 712 F.3d 173, 176 (4th Cir. 2013); Hooters of America, Inc. v. Phillips, 173 F.3d 933, 938-39 (4th Cir. 1999); Murray v. United Food & Commercial Workers Int’l Union, 289 F.3d 297, 302 (4th Cir. 2002).

        Here the arbitration agreement denied Plaintiff access to a neutral forum because Defendant had exclusive control over the list of arbitrators from which employees were required to select.  In the Fourth Circuit an employer may not retain this exclusive right.  Murray, 289 F.3d at 303.  Defendant’s promise in the agreement to provide a list of impartial arbitrators was not deemed sufficient to overcome the lack of mutuality in the arbitration selection process.  In addition the arbitration agreement was vague with respect to the rules to be followed, thereby providing a further reason to challenge the neutrality of the forum.

        The full opinion is available in PDF here.
        Post written by Maria A. Stubbings

        Friday, January 25, 2013

        TIG Insurance Company v. Monongahela Power Company (Ct. of Special Appeals)

        Filed: December 21, 2012
        Opinion by Judge Shirley M. Watts
        Held:  Pennsylvania law applies to the interpretation of insurance policies where the policies are delivered to and paid from a company’s office within that state.

        Facts: Appellee, a Maryland corporation, is a holding company that purchased numerous insurance policies from various insurance companies (hereafter collectively referred to as “insurers”). Among these policies were four Excess Insurance policies issued by appellant, which provided indemnification of appellee for loss exceeding certain amounts. On each of these policies, appellee listed a New York address.

        In 2001 and 2002, appellee demanded that the insurers indemnify it for costs related to the settlement of asbestos suits that triggered the policies and informed insurers to expect thousands of additional. Following these demands, one of the insurers filed a complaint against appellee and the other insurers requesting a declaratory judgment for the purpose of determining what obligations were owed under the policies. In 2010, appellee filed a motion for partial summary judgment requesting that the court find that Pennsylvania law apply to all policies made within a certain timeframe. It argued that the policies were “made” in Pennsylvania because the policies were accepted through payment of premiums by its insurance managers in that state.  Appellant joined in the arguments of another insurer, contending that New York law should apply due to appellee's headquarters there.  The trial court granted appellee’s motion for partial summary judgment.

        Analysis: The court engaged in a thorough analysis of contract construction, explaining that insurance policies are contracts and under the doctrine of lex loci contractus, absent a contractual choice of law provision, a contract will be governed by the law of the state where the last act necessary to complete the contract occurs. For insurance policies, Maryland appellate courts have consistently held that this occurs in the state where “the policy is delivered and premiums are paid.” In this case, there was undisputed evidence that this occurred in Pennsylvania.  The record showed that: 1) appellee’s insurance department was located in Pennsylvania; 2) its insurance broker was also located in that state; 3) it was the general practice of appellee for insurance policies to be received by the insurance broker and forwarded to appellee’s Pennsylvania office; 4) it considered itself bound by a policy after the policy was received in its Pennsylvania office, at which point it would begin paying premiums; and 5) premium payments were made from its Pennsylvania office.

        Appellant contended that New York law should apply because appellee was headquartered in New York, making it reasonable to conclude that the policies were delivered to that state. The court, however, noted that a company being headquartered in a state does not mean that all contracts into which the company enters are made in that state. Because appellant offered nothing to show that the policies were delivered to New York or that the premiums were paid from New York, the court affirmed the lower court’s grant of partial summary judgment and found that Pennsylvania law applies to the interpretation of the insurance policies.

        The court went on to address a separate issue raised by appellant regarding whether, under Pennsylvania law, appellant is entitled to a set-off against the appellee’s loss which reflects the settling insurers’ proportionate shares of coverage for responsibility of the loss. 

        The full opinion is available in  PDF.

        Monday, December 17, 2012

        CR-RSC Tower I, LLC v. RSC Tower I, LLC (Ct. of Appeals)

        Filed: November 27, 2012
        Opinion by Judge Sally D. Adkins

        Held: Where two parties enter into a contract for the lease and development of real estate and one party subsequently breaches that contract, evidence of post-breach market conditions is not admissible to prove lost profits if the parties did not contemplate the market conditions when they contracted.

        Facts: Landlord entered into two 90-year ground leases with Tenant, a "successful real estate company," related to a tract of land in Maryland, consisting of two adjoining properties. Under the ground leases, Tenant agreed to construct two apartment buildings that it would sell after construction and initial rental. After temporary modifications, the parties reverted to their original plan to build two apartments and arranged financing for the first building. However, as construction began, Landlord failed to provide estoppel certificates and, as a result, financing fell through. In November 2006, Tenant sued for breach of contract, seeking recovery of lost profits. 

        Tenant based its claim on market projections as of December 2006, the time of the initial breach. Landlord contended that, because in 2006 the apartments weren't projected to be fully leased until 2010 and 2012, the actual market conditions in 2010 and 2012 were relevant. Landlord sought to show that under the conditions of the current market, Tenant would not have profited regardless of whether there was a breach. Landlord offered expert testimony about the real estate market crisis in 2008–2010, a time when “the world . . . changed” and “the cataclysmic events of 2008 in the economy” took place. 

        The trial court ruled against Landlord on several motions, including, among other things, that Landlord could not introduce evidence of the 2008 crash in the real estate market to show that Tenant would not have made profits.

        The jury found for Tenant, awarding it over 36 million dollars in collateral damages. Landlord appealed, alleging that the trial court erred in not admitting evidence of “post-breach market conditions.” It argued that such evidence is a necessary part of any lost profits claim and that, without it, a plaintiff cannot meet the requirement that lost profits be proved with “reasonable certainty.” 

        The Court of Special Appeals affirmed the trial court’s decision, citing the “general principle” that contract damages are measured at the time of breach.

        Analysis: The Court engaged in a lengthy discussion of measuring lost profits and reliance  damages. The Court determined that “consequential lost profits are calculated with reference to what the parties can reasonably be said to have anticipated when they entered into the contract.” The Court explained that, for this reason, “circumstances that cannot be said to have been ‘known to the parties’ when they contracted—such as a post-breach boom or bust in the market—should not affect the measure of consequential damages that would ‘ordinarily arise’ according to the ‘intrinsic nature of the contract.’” 

        The Court explained, although many contracts are made with the possibility of future market downturns and, accordingly, allocate such risk between the parties, the contract in this case did not. Under this contract, the success of both parties depended on a relatively stable market and it could not be said that a subsequent, unforeseen, “cataclysmic”  market crash was within the parties’ contemplation.  Thus, the Court held that the trial court did not err in excluding evidence of post-breach market conditions.

        The Court went on to discuss separate issues raised by Landlord regarding waiver of the attorney client privilege and joint and several liability.

        The full opinion is available in PDF.